December 27, 2006
Lists, 12/27.
Critics are forever prefacing their top tens with disclaimers and precautions: Ask me on another day, and I'll give you a different list altogether. Well, they're not kidding. Case in point. Compare and contrast Dennis Lim's ballot for the indieWIRE Critics' Poll and his annotated "Best of 2006" just posted at the main site. Interesting, yes? Maybe more critics should float a top ten towards the end of December and then again in early January, once the year-end storm has calmed.
At any rate, two more lists at the main site: Iraq docs, listed by GCers' ratings, and Calvin Souther and Tiffany Harker list the top seven most F*d-up films to hit DVD in 2006.
If you're still working your way through the iW Critics' Poll, brace yourself. Here comes indieWIRE again with top tens from iW editors, writers and contributors. Also: Jonny Leahan: "2006 spawned a wealth of excellent documentary films, a high percentage of which dealt with either matters of music or politics - and many even combined the two themes."
These are the days when the jostling for position on the Top Tens chart and Awards Scoreboard at Movie City News begins to suggest something like consensus. List junkies: you know where to keep an eye.
Dave Kehr: "Here are the 25 films named by the Librarian of Congress, James Billington, to the National Film Registry for 2006."
"Some of the most interesting art/indie movies that I saw or heard about this year were self-distributed movies," writes Sujewa Ekanayake. "In celebration, here are some lists."
"There's such an uneasy, nervous collection of films, with all sorts of wartime anger and confusion spilling outside the frame," writes Sean Burns, introducing his top ten for the Philadelphia Weekly. "On the surface these pictures might seem an eclectic bunch, but underneath the hood they've all got moving parts date-stamped with the year 2006." His #1: Children of Men.
Cinematical editor James Rocchi also has Children up there; and Cinematical's Christopher Campbell 'fesses up to his "Top 10 Guilty Pleasures of 2006."
With none of last year's fanfare or introductory warm-ups, Time's Richards Corliss and Schickel post a curt top ten. Their #1: Letters From Iwo Jima.
Bad Lit's "Movie of the Year": Waiting for NESARA: "The NESARA referred to in the title is a bizarre cult that believes that George W Bush is a space alien preventing the return of Jesus Christ in his spaceship to save us all."
You'll have to scroll down a bit, but when you do, you'll see that Howl's Moving Castle tops Anime Talk's 10 at DVD Talk.
Among City Pages' "Artists of the Year": Sweet Land director Ali Selim, television writer David Simon (The Wire), Friends with Money director Nicole Holofcener, David Lynch, Neil Young and Robert Altman.
Posted by dwhudson at December 27, 2006 10:26 AM
It makes me extremely happy that Lim calls Inland Empire "an unwitting companion to another forbidding 2006 masterwork, Scott Walker's album The Drift, matching both its bottomless terror and its blindsiding stabs of beauty." For the past few months, I've been inversely oversimplifying the Walker album (coincidently, my favorite of 2006) as "the Inland Empire of music."
Posted by: Aaron Hillis at December 27, 2006 12:53 PMDennis Lim's Greencine list is different for a simple reason: different list rules. His Greencine list mixes released, unreleased, and in the case of Out 1, I don't know what for sure. The indieWIRE/Voice list required separate categories. If you put those categories together, you get something like the Greencine one.
But yes, it's true: following hidebound schedules, most polls solicit critics before the bump of end-of-year releases, short-changing good movies for posterity.
Posted by: Rinn at December 28, 2006 10:47 AMMy own list - soon to appear on GreenCine too - will probably change, at least in my own head, once, if not several times after it goes up, due to some of those reasons you mention. I also tend to agonize over some of my choices, then have more perspective later, then see something else after the fact that I thought was better than Film A, and so on. Lists are just a fun way to assess one's own take on the year past, to point to favorite films that may have been missed (which Dennis Lim does a particularly nice job of), evaluate the films we liked the most and why, compare to other people's lists, gnash teeth when we realize we've forgotten something, agonize over it, then let go and move on.
But the timing/schedules of the whole thing definitely play a big part on what ends up on each list.
CP
Posted by: Craig P at December 29, 2006 11:48 AM




Subscribe to GreenCine Daily by email